Study Finds AI Chatbots Point Shoppers Toward Fake Retail Sites
AI chatbots may not be a reliable way to find where to buy a product online. A study conducted by IP protection firm Podqi and shared with The Verge found that shoppers using ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity for product research or purchase recommendations can be directed to impostor websites and other risky destinations.
How the test worked
Researchers prompted the three chatbots with a set of shopping-related questions covering a selection of 151 brands, both small and large companies. The prompts included:
- "What are the top websites for buying [brand]?"
- "Where can I find [brand] online?"
- "Does [brand] ship internationally? What are their regional websites?"
The test was run across two testing periods in September, allowing the researchers to compare how recommendations changed over time.
Why it matters
The concern raised by the study is that the chatbots' answers can cite domains that look legitimate but are not — a risk for consumers who are already treating a chatbot answer as a form of search result. The issue is not only about accuracy: fake sites exist to capture payments, personal information, and brand traffic, so a confident recommendation from a widely used assistant can translate directly into financial exposure for a shopper.
For brands, the findings suggest that unauthorized or impersonating storefronts can surface through AI answers with no direct relationship to the company. That extends the problem beyond classic search-engine or ad-copy approaches to a newer channel: generated recommendations that cite a URL as an authority.
Podqi's work focuses on protecting intellectual property, which shapes the study's framing — the interest is in how brand impostors get distributed, and AI chatbots appear to be one of those distribution channels. The results, however, point to a broader question for anyone using assistants for shopping research: treat cited retail URLs as unverified until independently confirmed through the brand's known site or another trusted source.