News

Study finds in-school cellphone bans modestly improve learning; researchers look beyond the classroom

A nationwide study suggests that keeping cellphones out of classrooms has a measurable, if modest, effect on how much students learn.

Researchers from Harvard University and affiliated institutions compared learning outcomes under in-school cellphone bans, and estimated that the policy is roughly equivalent to adding one to two extra weeks of school to the academic year. On that measure, bans account for about half of the total learning loss observed in US students between 2013 and the 2020 Covid-19 pandemic.

The results support the case for restricting phones during the school day, though the effect size suggests bans are not a complete answer to the broader learning problems that emerged over that period. Learning losses during the pandemic years had multiple contributors, and classroom phone rules appear to address only part of the picture.

That is what motivates the next phase of the research: looking beyond the school building. The team wants to determine whether students' phone use outside of class contributes to the remaining learning loss, a question that has been difficult to isolate because off-campus phone habits vary widely between students and school districts.

The researchers plan to draw on the conditions of Meta's multibillion-dollar settlement from earlier this year, which provides an unusual source of data and legal ground for studying how social-media and phone use affects young people's learning and wellbeing.

For now, the headline finding is a useful data point for schools and policymakers weighing phone-restriction policies: the classroom ban appears to work, at roughly the scale of a couple of extra instructional weeks per year.

Sources